| "Pharaohs and Pyramids" by George Hart<br>Reviewed by Hmt. Rev. Tamara Siuda (AUS)
|
"Pharaohs and Pyramids:
A Guide Through Old Kingdom Egypt"
George Hart, with foreward by Professor Barry Cunliffe
The Herbert Press, UK, 1991.
ISBN: 1-871569-36-2
"Man fears time, but time fears the pyramids," begins a modern Egyptian
proverb. Even to the last millennia of the Kemetic culture, the stone "houses of
eternity" left as legacies by ephemeral god-kings were a puzzlement, an exhibition of
unexplained majesty. In all periods of later Kemetic history, it was high compliment and
the ultimate reverence to be able to compare oneself to "the first time" when
Kemet's splendor had yet been untouched by outside forces such as invasion and
international diplomacy. The Old Kingdom's influence was felt through the entire Kemetic
culture, and continues to the present day, as everyone from UFO fanatics to racial purists
tries to stake a claim to the pyramids that were the splendor of the Two Lands in the time
of kings known only to us by their monuments: Nar-mer, Djoser, Seneferu, Khufu, Khafra,
Unas, Pepi.
George Hart, already known to the scholarly and popular Egyptophile community for a
delightful quick reference to Netjer (The Gods and Goddesses of Ancient Egypt), has
here compiled an illustrated history of the end of the Predynastic Period and the entire
Old Kingdom of Kemet, as revealed through surviving monuments and the archaeological
record. This book will have wide appeal to beginner and expert alike. It's also the first
book on the subject I've seen that deals objectively with the process of pyramid building,
showing once and for all that it can be proven that not only did pyramid buiding evolve
over time to culminate in the glory of the Great Pyramid at modern-day Giza--but that the
building of pyramids served a social welfare and religious function, firmly placing it
into the realm of possibility for the very society whose culture seems synonymous with
them. With the exception of a few unnecessary conjectures here and there, Hart takes on
the question of who built the pyramids and why with facts, diagrams and photographs,
taking the wind once and for all out of the sails of the currently re-emerging
"pyramids as the product of alien technology" theories.
Hart then continues to describe the splendor of the rest of this ancient culture, as
revealed through the murals and statuary of nobles' tombs. While he treats the tomb of
Niankhkhnum and Khnumhotep (popularly known as "The Tomb of the Two Brothers"
even though it shows two men openly and without derision as lovers) with traditional
British understatement, Hart's analysis of what is revealed on these walls and in the eyes
of these statues is at once charming and reflected both in today's Egyptian culture and in
the universal human landscape. The book is chronologically arranged, with plenty of
geneaological tables, maps and photographs, most in color.
An additional, interesting feature of the book's layout is in its description of sites
through the form of a walking tour; it would be possible to literally take the book with
you to the site and let it lead you to the scenes or monuments described.
My only disappointment in this book is Hart's usage of early Egyptologists' (pre-20th
Century) names for some rulers, which were discarded by mainstream Egyptology decades ago
after a linguistic mistake was corrected. While scribes throughout Kemet's history wrote
regnal names in a stilted order by putting divine elements first to honor the Netjer
mentioned, the names were not _pronounced_ in the same order the symbols were read; hence,
for example, a cartouche reading "Ra-kha-ef" would actually be pronounced
"Kha-ef-ra," the "Chephren" of the Greeks, a Giza pyramid builder.
Hart's usage of "backwardness" isn't consistent, either; while Hart writes
"Radjedef" and "Rakhaef" for Djedefra and Khafra of the Fourth
Dynasty, he calls the next ruler, correctly, "Menkaura," and all the rulers of
Dynasty Five with "Ra" names are correctly referenced. This causes unnecessary
complication and confusion for those seeking to crossreference this book with other
sources.
If you're looking for a good pre-Empire history of Kemet, this is a great one!

<< Previous
||
Table of Contents
||
Next >>
|